• U.S.
  • Courts

Anesthetized Patient Accidentally Records Doctors Insulting Him During Surgery

2 minute read

A Virginia man has been awarded $500,000 in medical malpractice and punitive damages by a jury after his phone’s voice recorder, accidentally left on during a procedure, captured cruel and mocking comments his doctors made about him while he was under anesthesia.

559537351
Robert Daly—Caiaimage/Getty Images

In the recording, which jurors heard as part of the three-day trial that took place in mid June, anesthesiologist Tiffany Ingham can be heard with other doctors and assistants calling the man (who remained anonymous in the case) a “wuss” and a “retard,” the Washington Post reports. “After five minutes of talking to you in pre-op, I wanted to punch you in the face,” Ingham says.

The recording also caught the doctors calling the man names, mocking his health, and planning how to avoid him after the surgery. At one point, Ingham calls the patient “annoying” and suggests that the gastroenterologist performing the surgery fake an urgent summons in order to escape a post-op discussion.

Farid Khairzada, one of the jurors in the case, told the Post that the man had asked for $1.75 million and that the $500,000 was a compromise between a juror who did not believe the man deserved to win any money and at least one who felt he should receive more.

“We finally came to a conclusion that we have to give him something, just to make sure that this doesn’t happen again,” Khairzada said.

[Washington Post]

Behind TIME's Plastic Surgery Cover With Fashion Photographer Miles Aldridge

From TIME Magazine's shoot for the June 29th cover story, Nip. Tuck. Or Else.
From TIME Magazine's shoot for the June 29th cover story, Nip. Tuck. Or Else.Miles Aldridge for TIME
From TIME Magazine's shoot for the June 29th cover story, Nip. Tuck. Or Else.
From TIME Magazine's shoot for the June 29th cover story, Nip. Tuck. Or Else.Miles Aldridge for TIME
3-D, 2010
3-D, 2010Miles Aldridge, Courtesy Steven Kasher Gallery
I Only Want You to Love Me #1, 2011
I Only Want You to Love Me #1, 2011Miles Aldridge
I only Want You To Love Me, 2011
I only Want You To Love Me, 2011Miles Aldridge
Actress #6
Actress #6Miles Aldridge, Courtesy Steven Kasher Gallery
A Drop of Red #2, 2001
A Drop of Red #2, 2001Miles Aldridge, Courtesy Steven Kasher Gallery
Spot the Fake #1, 2006
Spot the Fake #1, 2006Miles Aldridge, Courtesy Steven Kasher Gallery
Bold Gold #2
Bold Gold #2Miles Aldridge 2006, Courtesy Steven Kasher Gallery
Immaculée #5, 2007
Immaculée #5, 2007Miles Aldridge
Immaculée #3, 2007
Immaculée #3, 2007Miles Aldridge
The Cult of the Self #5, 2013
The Cult of the Self #5, 2013Miles Aldridge
The Cult of the Self #2, 2013
The Cult of the Self #2, 2013Miles Aldridge
Hanne Gaby OdieleMiles Aldridge
Mannequin Thriller #1, 2013
Mannequin Thriller #1, 2013Miles Aldridge
Semi-Detached #2, 2012
Semi-Detached #2, 2012Miles Aldridge
Red Marks #1, 2003
Red Marks #1, 2003Miles Aldridge, Courtesy Steven Kasher Gallery
The Rooms #4, 2011
The Rooms #4, 2011Miles Aldridge
Kiss of Death #1, 2008
Kiss of Death #1, 2008Miles Aldridge

More Must-Reads from TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com