The Price Of Failure
The ruble's free fall triggers a very scary global financial panic
By JOSHUA COOPER RAMO
If you think you had a tough week last week--and who didn't, with
the Dow off 482 points?--you might perk up after a chat with
Stanley Druckenmiller. A six-footer with deep-set eyes and a grin
that creeps sideways across his face like a stock ticker, he has
been labeled the world's brightest currency trader, an Einstein
of the pits. Druckenmiller's paycheck is signed by George Soros,
for whom he oversees $22 billion. Uh, make that a little less.
Last week Druckenmiller watched helplessly as the Russian debt
market vaporized into fiscal neutrinos, taking the last of $2
billion of Soros' Russia-invested money into hyperspace. Fessing
up on CNBC, the crestfallen trader blinked at the camera and
softly explained that the Moscow meltdown had turned "a very good
year into a mediocre one."
The $2 billion markdown is small change compared with the
devastation that the Russian collapse inflicted on central banks
and stock markets in other countries, even those seemingly out of
harm's way. Venezuelans stumbled through a valiant, painful
defense of their bond market, Brazilians scrambled to save their
currency, and Americans watched a nervous stock market plummet,
pause and plummet again. Russia's slide was a reminder that every
investment is at heart a bet on the future. Last week the future
looked awful.
The chaos started two weeks ago, when the Yeltsin government
effectively devalued the Russian ruble by about 34%. To some
folks, this limited devaluation appeared to be a wise move that
might strengthen Russia's exhausted central bank. Since the
Russian economy had been quietly improving last year, a small
relaxation of the currency could have helped boost demand for
Russian exports, which would have pushed the recovery along. From
an Economics 101 perspective, the approach was a sensible--if
risky--way to help Russia through a tough patch. Even Soros argued
that a small devaluation, linked with other measures, was
prudent.
The problem was that Russia's banking system was a mess, which
meant the well-intentioned devaluation quickly turned into a
free-for-all. The particular dilemma was that Russia's banks
were loaded down with foreign-currency debt, which meant that a
decrease in the value of the ruble made repayment more
expensive. This made the temptation to default almost
irresistible--especially since Russian banks are generally seen
as checkbooks for a new class of oligarchs. As the soon to be
departed Russian government heads huddled in Moscow to figure a
way out of this crisis and to consider how to deal with the
devaluation, the halls of their offices began to fill with very
worried, very powerful bankers. They had come to deliver a
lethal message: they would no longer pay their debts.
Faced with an impossible choice between closing these banks and
defaulting on foreign debt, Russia's leaders placated the
oligarchs for the time being. The forced restructuring will allow
a 90-day moratorium on banks' foreign debt and a rescheduling of
$40 billion in domestic debt. Given the decline of the ruble,
this was roughly the same as announcing an intention to pay off
debt with green cheese. Investors, to no one's surprise, rushed
to sell out, until the limp, overloaded markets finally shut
down. Russia, deprived of international capital--James Dorn of the
Cato Institute calls it "financial morphine"--went into shock.
Explained Steven Halliwell, a partner at River Capital
Management: "As far as we can tell, Russia is in an absolute
panic situation."
The panic spread. Hardest hit were countries in Latin America. To
outsiders, the link seemed strange: nations such as Venezuela and
Brazil have very little exposure to Russia, but their economies
suffered nonetheless. "Latin markets are right to think that this
is a moment of complete irrationality," says Bond Snodgrass, an
analyst at Warburg Dillon Read in Mexico City. "But this should
finally drive home the point: Mexico is no longer just Mexico,
Brazil is no longer just Brazil. They're all part of one asset
class now, and investors aren't distinguishing between any of
them." And the dramatic drop in the U.S. markets--after months of
talk about a "Goldilocks economy"--demonstrated once again that
markets hate nothing so much as uncertainty. Russia's pain
evidently would also be the world's.
PAGE 1 | PAGE 2
|

|