|
 |  | |
|
|
about Asia Buzz
Asia Buzz: Sexy Singapore?
Pushing the boundary in the control-minded city-state
By ERIC ELLIS
January 16, 2001
Web posted at 5:30 p.m. Hong Kong time, 4:30 a.m. EDT
Sammyboy.com is not a website you'd want your 11-year-old surfing into
unsupervised. It's deep and content-rich, it's alluring, and, in the main, quite
well-written. In places it is also funny. That's the glass half-full way of
looking at it. The half-empty way is that it's lewd, crass and offensive. And
that there's nothing funny about pornography.
Yes, Sammyboy is a porn site, aimed very directly at the country which arguably
least tolerates porn: Singapore. Which is all very well except Official
Singapore has yet to close it down. The site has been up and down, so to speak,
several times over the past week, and on each occasion it was the site's
webmaster, a Samuel Leong, who made the call to shut his own site down. Not the
authorities.
| |
ASIA BUZZ |
|
Asia Buzz: Blowtorch
Will Colin Powell have the answers to America's problems?
-
Monday, January 15, 2001
Culture on Demand: The Goss on Gucci
Pass the dog bones, please
-
Saturday, January 13, 2001
Letter from Japan: Hard Medicine
The "Japan way" has failed. It's time to act
-
Friday, January 12, 2001
Asia Buzz: Google
There is no other search engine worth using
-
Tuseday, January 9, 2001
Asia Buzz: Truth in Advertising
Savvy advertising slogans could help our region's embattled leaders
-
Monday, January 8, 2001
Asia Buzz: Making a Difference
Connecting nuns in East Timor to the Internet
-
Thursday, January 4, 2001
|
|
ASIAWEEK |
Intelligence
The story behind today's news from the editors of Asiaweek
|
|
What's happening here? Has the nanny state loosened up and is now tolerating
porn? Can that be happening? As with many things in Singapore, not everything is
as it seems.
Leong (if that's his real name) says he's not running a porn site. Instead he's
running a community service. Sex, he says, is a bodily function that all of us
at some point do, and all he's simply doing is bringing it out into the open.
I've had a close look at Sammyboy -- there, I admit it -- and I have decided
that it is in fact a porn site. But one with qualifications. Where Sammyboy
starts being a porn site -- and thus inviting the wrath of authorities -- is
where it links to very serious porn sites, the ones that you sometimes click
into by accident and then spend 10 frustrating minutes trying to close down all
the recurring browsers. If Sammyboy didn't carry those links, then Leong's
argument might stack up a bit more firmly.
Beyond that, Sammyboy is morphing into a kind of samizdat outlet where
Singaporeans vent and satirize life in the city-state. That's another no-go
area, where the government's patience has traditionally been pretty short. But
if you hold your breath and dive in, the site can be pretty funny, and sometimes
illuminating. There's links to information about bad Singapore Inc. investments
that don't get talked about too much, a "conservative Asian values forum," and a
pretty funny cartoon that speaks to the national ideology of making money.
Another taste of Sammy's sense of humor comes when you log on. A window appears
warning "all SPH journalists to keep out. You are not welcome." SPH is
Singapore's print media near-monopoly, the publisher of the pro-government
Straits Times and New Paper. The latter, for your information, has been running
a campaign to shut Sammy down. But it's a funny kind of campaign. The New Paper
wrote a scolding article about the site, which simply served to lift Sammyboy's
profile among the Singaporeans it warned not to surf there.
Sammy himself is a bit of a mystery. The site is hosted in California but
registered to a Samuel Leong, which is kind of a Singapore Everyman name, in
Auckland, New Zealand. I called the number on the registration site and spoke to
a Morgan Yeo, who happened to be Singaporean but claimed to know nothing of
Sammyboy, or Samuel Leong. "I just run a used car yard here," he pleaded.
So, what are authorities doing about it? So far, not much, but it's still early
days. The Singapore Broadcasting Authority which regulates these things told the
New Paper that "the Samuel Leong website is but one of countless number of
pornographic sites on the Internet. "Given the borderless nature of the Internet
and the vast number of undesirable sites on the Net, there is a limit of what
legislation can do," said a spokesman.
Sites like Sammyboy test control regimes like Singapore. It's impossible to
condone porn but where does it stop being porn and start being a content site.
And what does it look like when the government mantra is to open up, become a
media center, and then bans sites that claim not to strictly fall into the porn
category?
My tip is that Singapore will jump on Sammyboy. And if Sammyboy -- or Leong --
was smart, and really wanted to make some money from advertisers, he'd take down
the hardcore links and emphasis the user-guide aspect. And then he and the
Singapore authorities could be talking the same language -- trying to help
procreation.
Write
to TIME at mail@web.timeasia.com
TIME Asia home
|
|
LATEST HEADLINES:
|
Click Here for the latest regional analysis from TIME Asia
|
|
|
