When Push Comes to Shove
After anti-Japanese protests in China, how can relations between the two powers get back on track?
Textbook Tensions
History 101: Rewrite the Past
Viewpoint
It's time for China and Japan to stop provoking each other

Map
Sea of Contention

China and Japan
Can We talk
[29/11/2004]
West Meets East
How Europe fell in love with China
[10/18/2004]
Indicates premium content

E-mail your letter to the editor




EUGENE HOSHIKO / AP 
BARRAGE: Protesters throw eggs and paint balls at the Japanese consulate in Shanghai

When Push Comes to Shove
After anti-Japanese protests in China, how can relations between the two powers get back on track?

Email or Print this article print article email TIMEasia Subscribe

Posted Monday, April 18, 2005; 20:00 HKT
Xu Jin, a 29-year-old marketing executive in Shanghai, was fast asleep when the beep of her cell phone woke her up. It was a text message from her boss urging her to boycott Japanese goods from May 1-June 1 to protest Tokyo's refusal to fully atone for its brutal wartime record. Although her apartment is packed with Japanese products, Xu forwarded the message to all 50 contacts on her mobile. "I've never liked the Japanese because of their government's attitude toward World War II," says Xu. "I am not a nationalist, but since everyone is boycotting Japanese products, I should, too." Similar sentiments were flying over cellular and online networks last week as angry Chinese urged one another to join anti-Japanese street protests. "Bring old tomatoes and rotten eggs to throw at the Japanese pigs," stated one e-mail message, complete with a map of how to get to the Japanese consulate in Shanghai. "When burning Japanese flags and pictures of [Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro] Koizumi," advised another, "please be careful not to light your clothes on fire."

Right now, everyone needs to be careful around combustible material; these flames could get out of control. After an enormous march against Japan in Shanghai last Saturday, relations between Asia's two leading powers have deteriorated into their worst state for years. Japanese officials have urged Beijing to stop the demonstrations on the mainland while Japan's business community—anxious to protect an economy that is increasingly dependent upon China trade—has called for constructive dialogue. But not all of Tokyo's actions have been conciliatory. Last Wednesday, Japan's Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry began accepting Japanese companies' bids to test drill for natural gas in East China Sea waters that China claims as its own. "This is a provocation to China's rights and interests," responded Qin Gang, China's Foreign Minister. "We demand that Japan pay attention to China's concerns, or the consequences will depend upon Japan."

Beijing has been placing a lot of demands on its neighbor over the past few weeks. What started with China's opposition to Japan's bid to join an expanded United Nations Security Council (China already has a seat) subsequently ballooned into violent public attacks on Japanese diplomatic missions and businesses in several Chinese cities that continued through the weekend. In Shanghai, throngs of mostly young Chinese gathered in the vast People's Square to begin a march to the Japanese consulate across town. At first, the atmosphere was less menacing riot and more street carnival. But along the way, angry protesters broke away and vandalized Japanese restaurants with paint, rocks and bottles. By the time the demonstrators reached the consulate, tempers were fever-hot. For six hours, mobs burned Japanese flags, threw paint bombs, rocks, tomatoes and eggs at the building. Japan's Foreign Ministry lodged a formal complaint with Beijing, saying: "Whatever the reason for this violent and destructive behavior, we will not accept it."

Rationales for an outpouring of anti-Japanese rage were readily available: Japan's Education Ministry this month approved textbooks that whitewash the country's wartime atrocities, and China has long held that Japan has failed to properly atone for its past militaristic sins. Snubbing Japan's Security Council bid last week, China's Premier Wen Jiabao said: "Only a country that respects history ... [and] wins over the trust of people in Asia and the world at large can take greater responsibilities in the international community." He ignored the fact that Japan is the world's second largest economy and the second biggest contributor to the U.N.

Continued...



Smoldering Hatreds [Apr. 11, 2005]
Closer economic ties aren't easing historic grudges between Japan, South Korea and China

Respect and Resentment [Nov. 22, 2004]
Japan is becoming impatient with demands that it should constantly apologize for what happened more than 60 years ago

Patriot Games [Nov. 22, 2004]
Stoked by nationalism, a new generation of Chinese feels growing hostility toward Japan

Asia's Odd Couple [Nov. 22, 2004]
The region's future depends on whether China and Japan can get along. Are the countries' leaders up to the task?

Leave the Past Behind [Nov. 22, 2004]
It's time for China and Japan to stop bickering about history

More Related Items | Search all issues of TIME Magazine




Table of Contents
Subscribe to TIME

ADVERTISEMENT
QUICK LINKS: Cover Story | Textbook Tensions | Viewpoint | Map | Back to TIMEasia.com Home
FROM THE APRIL 25, 2005 ISSUE OF TIME MAGAZINE; POSTED MONDAY, APRIL 18, 2005


Copyright © 2006 Time Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.

Subscribe to TIME | Customer Service | FAQ | About TIME Asia | Search | Write to Us | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Press Releases | Media Kit