By LISA TAKEUCHI CULLEN
What is it like to be a geisha? I hated it. The wig itched, my back ached, and
about 1,000 tourists mobbed me for photos. Then again, I was only a maiko, or
novice geisha, for a day. Geisha "transformation" services are all the rage in
the ancient temple town of Kyoto, where a girl -- or, in fact, a boy -- can
dress up as a geisha. So my experience is pretty shallow. But Liza Dalby's is
not. While in her 20s, Dalby, an American, became the first and only Westerner to
enter the so-called "world of willows and flowers." Researching geisha for a
doctorate in anthropology, she became one herself: Ichigiku of Pontocho. She
later wrote about her unique, insiders' experience in "Geisha" (University of
California Press, 1983), and subsequently became the leading American expert on
the subject. Author Arthur Golden studied her work for his best-selling book
"Memoirs of a Geisha," and Steven Spielberg has hired her as his consultant for
the film version of Golden's book. Dalby is also the author of "The Tale of
Murasaki" (Nan A. Talese/Doubleday, 2000), a historical novel set in 11th-
century Japan featuring the heroine, Lady Murasaki Shikibu. Dalby spoke to
TIME's Lisa Cullen. Edited excerpts:
What do you think of phony geishas like me who don kimonos and makeup and tromp
around town for just a day?
The only thing that bothers geisha about the fakes is that they're often
mistaken for the real thing. They hang out in places where foreigners and other
tourists go, and those people usually can't tell the difference. Some of the
girls don't watch their language; they chew gum; they even smoke! It's really
unbecoming.
I didn't chew gum.
That's good.
And I was really hungry.
Uh huh.
What made you become a geisha?
I was interested in studying geisha as a group of working women with a long
tradition in Japan. But I never ever thought I'd end up doing what I did. After
starting my research in Tokyo, I went to Kyoto for what I thought would be a
brief visit to look into the regional differences in geisha tradition. I ended
up spending most of my year there. While I was interviewing the woman who became
my geisha "mother," she said to me, "You can talk to us all you like during the
day when there are no customers, but you'll never understand until you see us
working at night." So she borrowed a kimono for me from a tall geisha, and
that's how it started.
Just like that.
Yeah, and I was in my mid-20s -- which is really too old to be a maiko [novice
geisha].
Do you think it's unseemly that I pretended to be a maiko at 29?
I've heard even old ladies get dressed up in maiko costumes these days.
You're a "gaijin" -- a foreigner. Why did they let you in?
I had a peculiar set of qualifications. One was that on my first trip to Japan
as a teenager, I became fascinated with the shamisen [a lute-like string
instrument]. It turned out to be a great way to get into the geisha world
because it gave me credibility. Another qualification was that I could speak
Japanese, and yet another was the ability to sit in the Japanese style for many
hours. Everybody talks about the standoffishness of Japanese society, and in
fact it did take me some time to get to know these people. But when I did, they
really took me in.
Is being a geisha still about sex?
No. And it hasn't been for a long time. Geisha exist to preserve traditional
art. I'd liken it to the kabuki dynasties -- the last bastion of a certain kind
of performing arts.
What about the geishas' male patrons? I mean, I can't imagine they just want to
watch them dance.
Most geisha have patrons, yes, for economic as well as emotional reasons. Geisha
don't marry -- if they marry, they give up being a geisha. The relationships
with the patrons tend to be long lasting. In any case, their sex life is very
much their own private business. I don't think it's helpful to talk about it as
prostitution.
Just who are these patrons?
Businessmen, mostly, and politicians -- as some recent scandals will attest.
After your book "Geisha" came out, were there a lot of American girls who wanted
to become one?
Over the years I've received a ton of letters from women who think they do. At
one point I practically ran a geisha-wanna-be counseling service on my computer.
Some of the women are drawn to the geisha life in a weird kind of feminist way:
they want to join a community of professional women who don't marry, devote
themselves to their art, and lead glamorous lives. But that's just as
unrealistic as the male fantasy of the geisha.
Was your geisha training hard? Like, could I do it?
A lot of the training is on the job. A young geisha starting out goes along with
her "older sister" and doesn't say much; she just learns by watching. That
relationship with the older sister teaches you about kinship and authority --
the ceremony in which you become sisters is a lot like a marriage ceremony. The
thing that draws women to the profession today is interest in the traditional
arts, which the geisha specialize in. As a maiko, I could already play the
shamisen, even better than some of the young Japanese geisha. But I had to learn
the style played at banquets, where they like to hear short songs.
What's the hardest part about becoming a geisha?
For Japanese girls, I think it's learning how to be comfortable around men. They
have to overcome their upbringing. Japanese girls aren't socialized to talk
freely and easily with men. And then there are the customs of the geisha world,
particularly in Kyoto -- the proper greetings to the older sister and such. Most
girls take three to four years to train; they learn to turn themselves into a
work of art, with their dress, face, and manner. But they spend most of the time
learning the art that they present to clients, which is primarily dance or
music. Being a dancer is the more glamorous skill -- "maiko," in fact, means
dancer -- so that's what most of the girls want to learn. But perhaps the
hardest part is learning to wear the kimono for hours on end.
How fast is the geisha community shrinking?
Fast. But that could change. Compared to 25 years ago, there's a new glamour
attached to being a geisha. Everybody knows about Arthur Golden's book, "Memoirs
of a Geisha," and the Steven Spielberg movie based on the book. Nowadays, young
girls are starstruck by maiko. I've heard the Kyoto registry office is having a
hard time weeding out those who aren't serious.
I'm sure the lousy economy doesn't help sustain the geisha business.
That's right. One of the reasons they call it the "water business" is because
it's closely tied to the swells in the economy. Corporations are the geishas'
major clients. If companies aren't doing well, they're not going to pay for
geisha services. In a community like Pontocho, there were between 80 and 100
geisha working when I was there [in the late '70s]. In the '80s, the numbers
shot up because times were so good. They dropped again in the '90s.
"Memoirs of a Geisha" portrayed the viciousness or backstabbing in the geisha
community. Was there a lot of that in your days?
Not in my experience, but that's probably because I worked in Pontocho. There's
a sharp difference in status among the five geisha communities in Kyoto. The
Gion, Pontocho and Kamishichiken geisha districts are the most prestigious, and
there's great respect among the geisha who work there. If you went to a fancy
party in the Higashiyama area, for instance, you'd see geisha from all three of
those districts working harmoniously together.
Your life is literally a world away now from the back streets of Pontocho.
What's stuck with you from that experience?
The one thing that stuck with me the longest was the sense of being in an all-
women community. I expected to find a lot of competition -- after all, they were
all competing for the same resources, the same customers. But after the clients
went home, the geishas only had each other.
For more information visit Liza Dalby's website