he fall of the Berlin Wall was supposed to bring on the end of history,
a time when great power confrontation would give way to the mere frictions
of the global marketplace and the lotions of consumerism would keep
everything running smoothly. Maybe someday. What we know for now is
that all around the edges of the peaceable Banana Republic, history
is still being made the old-fashioned way, with land mines and machetes.
James Nachtwey, a contract photographer for Time and
one of the best-known photojournalists of the past 20 years, works
along those edges. His passport has been stamped in some of the
most chaotic spots of the postwar era - Northern Ireland, Nicaragua,
El Salvador, Lebanon, Afghanistan - places where history always
seems to finish its work in a room where there is human waste spilled
across the concrete floor and blood smeared on the wall and the
bare light bulb of reason is not much help or comfort.
Inferno (Phaidon; 480 pages; $125) is the record of what Nachtwey
saw in the 1990s. After the fall of the communist dictator Ceaucescu,
he visited the ghoulish places where Romanian orphans were warehoused.
He moved on to Somalia and the Sudan where famine was used as a weapon
of mass destruction during civil war - and he photographed in the
refugee camps. In 1994 he worked in Rwanda and Zaïre during
the unsupervised ferocities of the Hutu massacre of the Tutsis and
the regional chaos it set in motion, including what may have been
the largest refugee exodus in history. Two years later he went to
Chechnya when Russia made its first ham-fisted attempt to suppress
the breakaway republic that it has recently bombed into submission
again. He went to Bosnia and Kosovo, where words have failed over
and again to convey the sheer sadism of what neighbor did to neighbor.
It's precisely when words fail that pictures like his are most
needed. Some of them are obscene in one literal sense of that word
- from ob scena, Latin for offstage - the sights to be kept from
the view of the audience. In the parts of the world where Nachtwey
does his work, public affairs have become not much more than a subdepartment
of the larger human impulse toward bloodlust. People are regularly
dismembered and disfigured. Their arms are blown off, their teeth
are broken, and they are starved. "I am trying to upset people,"
Nachtwey said recently. "I am trying to interrupt their day."
Sometimes, as we see from his pictures, people suffer in a setting
stripped of anything that identifies this as the modern world. There
are no cell phones, no plastic bags, just rigor mortis on bare ground,
and each shot is a primordial scene in which you recognize what
the late 20th century had in common with, say, the darkest moments
of the 6th. Sometimes his pictures include unnerving bits of modern
flotsam. In a Rwandan refugee camp in Zaïre a young man lies
dead in a heap of used plastic intravenous bags. Elsewhere in the
camp the corpses are pushed into piles by bulldozers. In Chechnya
a man's body leans against a wall while a neighbor helps himself
to a carton of American cigarettes that the dead man had been carrying.
Then someone else steals his hat and leaves his frozen body in the
snow.
It would be hard to call this book hopeful, but it does at least
end in Kosovo, the place where the West finally found the will and
the means to intervene effectively in a regional calamity. Inferno
is a book with the weight and density of one of those great 20th
century works of broken-hearted testimony, of the Holocaust documentary
Shoah or the string quartets of Shostakovich. With 382 black-and-white
pictures spread across oversize pages, it has the heft of a gravestone,
which is not so different from what it is, a cenotaph for the last
victims of the 20th century. What it tells us is that history did
not end with the conclusion of the cold war. It just moved to places
where its worst work was harder to see, or would have been if Nachtwey
had not gone there.
By Richard Lacayo