E-TRADING NIGHTMARES
PAGE 1 | 2 | 3
Bennett Rowe, 33, was so green when he started day trading three
years ago that he thought NASDAQ was a stock on the New York
Stock Exchange. But his ignorance of the financial markets didn't
stop him from trying to make a living from them. He was tired of
his job in retail as a salesman at the Ralph Lauren store in the
local Galleria, and his wife was expecting their first child. He
wanted a better life for his family.
Some of his old college buddies were day traders, so one day he
went to their office to see what it was all about. It looked
tough, but he thought he could handle it. He borrowed $80,000
from his father, said goodbye to Polo and took a desk at
Momentum, a day-trading brokerage in Houston where independent
traders pay commissions in exchange for a desk with a PC and
market access.
Instead of taking a course like so many others do before trying
their hand at this business, Rowe just sat down in front of a
Level II screen--which shows all the market makers' bid and sell
prices (rather than just the best bid and sell prices)--and
started trading. His friend at the next desk offered a
blow-by-blow account of what he was doing, and Rowe followed his
every move. "He'd say things like, 'I'm offering here,' 'I'm
bidding here,' and 'O.K., you own 1,000 shares of Cisco--now get
out of it,'" Rowe recalls. "It was no way to make money, but I
was just getting my feet wet."
Some days Rowe would be able to cover his commissions, but most
days he was in the hole. "That third week really stuck with me,"
he says. "I had left a job where I had been the top salesman for
10 years. And there I was, no paycheck coming in, no insurance
benefits, no security whatsoever. And instead of earning money
after a week's work, I was down $1,500." He sat and stewed all
weekend. When Monday came, he was back at his station, staring at
the screen in a panic.
Two months later, he was down $6,500. His losses were often the
result of hitting the wrong buttons on the keyboard--a common
blunder for newcomers still getting used to the system, he says.
Other times his ego got in the way: when his shares of Applied
Materials dropped 3/8, he hesitated--and sold an hour later, when
it was down 7/8. "I lost $900 because I didn't want to lose
$350."
Today Rowe compares day trading with running a marathon: try to
sprint out of the gate, he says, and you're dead. All day traders
should expect to lose money in the beginning--expect it and plan
for it. "I have yet to meet anybody who's made money in the first
couple of months," he says. "I don't have to make $1 million a
year, but I'm supporting my family and putting some money away."
Kimberly Hoover, 41, at left, was day trading before she knew there was a
name for it. It was 1996, and she had opened an account with
Charles Schwab. When the company started letting its customers
execute their own trades online, she was hooked. "I just noticed
that some companies would move three or four points in a day, and
that if you could get in at the bottom and out at the top, you
could make some good money," she says. She kept her Schwab
account, and she looked into getting a Level II screen but
decided that it would have meant giving up her day job as an
attorney--something she didn't want to do.
The experience was fun--until one day last August, when she lost
$18,000. She was trading in shares of Dell Computer, one of the
blue-chip high-tech stocks. The company suddenly went on a slide,
and rather than sit it out, Hoover bailed.
To day trade, "you have to have a strong stomach and realize that
there is a cycle to all of this," she says. "The reason I lost
all that money was that I panicked. I thought the market slide
was going to be long term, that I'd better get out, but the stock
rebounded higher than when I sold."
That rush to judgment--par for the course for day traders--has
reduced investment decisions to instinct, she says. Overall,
Hoover made money day trading, but the Dell debacle had a
chilling effect: she now holds on to a stock for several days,
even weeks. "I've decided that's what brings the best results."
PAGE 1 | 2 | 3
IMAGE CREDITS | PAM FRANCIS FOR TIME DIGITAL; DANUTA OTFINOWSKI FOR TIME DIGITAL