JEFF CHIU / APTHE OPTIMIST: Kerry gives a thumbs up at a rally in Columbus, Ohio
Kerry Struggles to Shake Optimism Deficit
Republican cries of pessimism push the Democratic challenger to seek a message both positive and critical
By
PERRY BACON/WASHINGTON
Cover Story: What Kind of President Would John Kerry Be?

Thursday, Jun. 17, 2004
The "average American" has long been a mainstay of the presidential campaign oratory "Tom" who wants to
send his son to college but can't afford the fees, or "Jane"
who benefited from a tax credit championed by the candidate. But John Kerry's newly-honed stump speech
emphasizes two people rarely mentioned in his
presidential run: Richard and Rosemary Kerry. In stops
this week in Ohio, Kerry has repeated talked
about being born in an Army hospital in Denver, about his
father Richard's service as a pilot in the Army Air Corps,
and about the community service work of his mother, Rosemary.
Why has Kerry suddenly started talking about his late
parents? Because while most voters are pretty set in their ideas of what defines President Bush, the two presidential campaigns are locked in a struggle to define John Kerry in the eyes of the electorate. The
Republicans, in millions of dollars worth of ads and through
the comments of President Bush and his surrogates,
hope to cast the presumptive Democratic nominee as soft on
security, inconsistent on other issues and pessimistic
about nearly everything. Implicitly, they're also suggesting he's out of touch with Americans. One
Republican operative told the New York Times last year that
Kerry "even looks French."
The Kerry campaign, for its part, wants to emphasize that their candidate not only shares the same concerns as average American, but is also able to identify with them. That's why Kerry is talking about his childhood,
trying to show he wasn't born a tall, occasionally-
aloof senator. In Columbus on Tuesday he not only
praised the work of his parents, but also noted that
his sister was born in nearby Dayton, because the
family moved often while Richard Kerry was in
the military. Candidate Kerry also now frequently lists
the jobs he held before reaching the Senate: soldier,
prosecutor and lieutenant-governor.
Kerry's effort to wrest control of his image from the Republicans is also an attempt
to blunt political attacks. As he continues to lament
the transfer of jobs overseas from places like Ohio,
Republicans have argued Kerry sounds like he is
opposed to free trade and anti-business.
So Kerry told a crowd at a fundraiser in Cincinnati
"I'm not a protectionist," while outlining how he would
seek to change some of the trade agreements. He's
lately proclaimed himself an "entrepreneurial
Democrat," seeking to emphasize his pro-business credentials.
An important element of Kerry's effort to define his candidacy is explaining why he decided to run. That's because the sharp decline in President Bush's approval
ratings in recent months have not translated into a proportionate increase in support for the Democrat, who most polls show either tying or leading the President by a narrow margin. Kerry campaign strategists argue that three events
will help cement positive impressions of their candidate in the public mind: his vice-presidential choice, the
Democratic convention when he accepts the nomination,
and the presidential debates in the fall. But many
Democratic strategists outside the campaign say part of
the problem is that Kerry hasn't told voters why he
wants to be president. That may be why in New Jersey and Ohio this week he repeatedly used the phrase "I'm running for
president to..." before launching into familiar pitches
on health care or foreign policy.
Kerry's most important challenge may be to portray himself
as an"optimist," a word he used repeatedly on the stump this week. President Bush and the GOP have painted Kerry as relentlessly negative on the state of
the economy, even as job growth improved
markedly over the last few months. It's not hard to
see where they got that idea. In almost every
speech, Kerry says that health care, gas prices and
tuition costs continue to increase while the wages of
many Americans go down. Kerry campaign manager Mary
Beth Cahill told reporters Monday that the President
was a "rudderless leader," and economic adviser Gene
Sperling likened the Bush's economic record to the
Great Depression and to last year's Detroit Tigers
baseball team, which won its last few games but still
posted one of the worst records in the history of
baseball.
Kerry has recently acknowledged that economic conditions
are getting better, but insists Americans should
expect the kind of job growth that was seen during the
Clinton years. By that measure, he says, the Republicans aren't optimistic enough. "I
believe in our abilities and so do you," Kerry said in
Cincinnati "I think the pessimism is those who say
gee, we're doing just great now."
Portraying optimism will be difficult for the
Kerry campaign. To win, every challenger needs to talk
about what's wrong with the incumbent, because for a candidate to be hired, voters
have to be convinced the other guy needs to be fired. But voters indicate they prefer hopeful candidates, so look for Kerry to continue to cast himself as positive, optimistic son of hard-working, service-minded Americans, even as he
paints President Bush's presidency as a terrible failure.
BACK TO TOP
|