"The Whole World Is Crying"
After the Beslan school slaughter, the Kremlin's handling of the siege comes under fire.
Communication Breakdown
Could the Kremlin have talked its way out of the massacre at School No. 1?
Atrocity in Beslan
The ghastly end to a school siege in the Russian republic of North Ossetia leaves a town in mourning for its lost children.
To Our Readers
Finding solidarity in sadness

End Game
How the seige came to a grisly conclusion
  Burying The Dead
The aftermath in Beslan — and beyond

Theatre of War Inside the raid that claimed 140 lives [11/4/02]

E-mail your letter to the editor

DMITRY LOVETSKY/AP
NATIONAL TRAGEDY: A woman cries while laying flowers at a wall in St. Petersburg covered with photos of the Beslan victims.

Finding Solidarity in Sadness
print article email TIMEeurope Subscribe

Posted Sunday, September 5, 2004; 11.27 BST
Paul Quinn-Judge, TIME'S Moscow bureau chief, has been covering the tragedies and atrocities of the Caucasus since 1996 immersing himself in the relentless pain of the place but never letting it cloud his vision. He has been to Chechnya and its neighboring republics nine times. He was in Grozny in 2000 just after the Russian army flattened it; he's been to the Pankisi Gorge in Georgia, a onetime haven for Chechen separatists and al-Qaeda operatives; and back in Moscow, he was at the Dubrovka Theater in October of 2002, where 170 people died after Chechen terrorists seized the building and took 800 hostages. So when he rushed to Beslan in North Ossetia last week catching a flight and driving through the night to cover the school siege he knew what to expect. "When you're faced with a tragedy of this magnitude, the feeling is devastation," Paul says. "Watching stretcher upon stretcher of kids coming out, dirty, half-naked, sometimes probably dead. It leaves you with a sense of deep emptiness."

Paul's report on the tragedy is vivid, poignant and shocking. His interview with Elena Kasumova, a teacher at Beslan's School No. 1 who survived the siege, is especially compelling. "Talking to someone who has gone through the most hellish experience, and can calmly, lucidly, dispassionately describe what happened is humbling," he says. "She saw the guerrillas do horrible things, yet remembers that one was a pleasant, nice-looking guy."

Most of all, Paul says, it's the heroism of ordinary people especially the civilians who rushed to save children as the bullets flew that sticks in the mind. "There's this fantastic solidarity that comes up in a community that has suffered such a crisis," he says. "I stayed with a family that had two children in the school. They didn't want to talk about it. They were worried, but stoic. Yet they spent their time worrying if I was getting enough to eat." Both children were wounded, but unlike so many others in Beslan last week, they survived.




Table of Contents
Subscribe to TIME

ADVERTISEMENT

On New Year's Eve, the Miseries of Minsk
As Russia hikes up the cost of gas for Belarus, the mood turns gloomy
Mogadishu at 60 Miles an Hour
Arms merchants are once again doing brisk business after a rapid change of power in this tough town, but so far the peace has held
The Year of The Nuke
A rundown of the world's nuclear powerhouses, and what to expect in the coming months


QUICK LINKS: "The Whole World Is Crying" | Communication Breakdown | Atrocity in Beslan | To Our Readers | Chechnya in TIME | Back to TIMEeurope.com Home
FROM THE SEPT. 13, 2004 ISSUE OF TIME MAGAZINE; POSTED SUNDAY, SEPT. 5, 2004.

 © 2004 Time Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
Subscribe | Customer Service | Search | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Media Kit | Press Releases
Try AOL UK for 1 month FREE | Try FOUR free issues of TIME
TIME Global Adviser | TIME Next | Chechnya in TIME
EDITIONS: TIME.com | TIME Asia | TIME Canada | TIME Europe | TIME Pacific | TIME For Kids