TIME EUROPE
September 25, 2000, Vol. 156 No. 13
Running on Empty
Protests against rising fuel costs should be a wake-up call for European governments that have lost touch with their electorates
By JAMES GRAFF Brussels
When protests against high oil prices began in France a few weeks ago, they seemed like a typically Gallic reflex, a kind of vive la différence exceptionalism. French farmers take to the streets often and enthusiastically, the fishermen on the Atlantic coast have long been ardent practitioners of "direct action," and for that matter les routiers have been known to blockade the autoroutes when the spirit moved them. As they do each time French citizens take to the streets, local and foreign commentators sagely pointed to the strength of France's revolutionary tradition and to the weakness of the French National Assembly — the implication being that it couldn't happen elsewhere.
This time those rationalizations proved wrong. It turns out many other Europeans, especially professional road users, are just like the French: fed up and organized enough to make their case with a vengeance. Last week Britain was all but paralyzed as no more than 2,500 truckers and farmers protested at oil refineries and depots throughout the country, persuading tanker drivers to stay inside. In Belgium, only bicycles and pedestrians could negotiate the normally chockablock ring around the city center, which looked like a truck stop parking lot for most of the week. Truckers in the Netherlands, Spain, Poland, Ireland, and Germany mounted protests of their own. Suddenly, an action that seemed to come out of nowhere threatened to bring Europe to a grinding standstill.
European Union politicians — often given to waxing europhoric about the 21st century wonders of the Internet and all the neat things that can be done with European-made, wap-enabled cell phones — got blindsided by an old-fashioned tax revolt over something very 20th century: the price of motor fuel. "For the first time ever a disruptive and potentially violent French labor protest became exemplary rather than lamentable to the rest of Europe," marveled François de Closets, a social commentator in Paris. "If this becomes habit-forming, we may be in for some trouble."
How did European politicians, particularly Britain's poll- and focus-group-driven Tony Blair, manage to miss this tsunami of public discontent? "Arrogant and out of touch" is how Kent trucking firm owner Ron Wood characterized the New Labour government from his perch on the ragged protest line at BP's giant Coryton refinery in southern England. "What comes out is their contempt."
It's one thing for angry demonstrators to feel that way. But what really got the attention of Europe's governments is that the protests, with their eerie echoes of the strike-plagued '70s, set off a sympathetic vibration among ordinary people despite the resulting inconveniences. Polls showed 78% of British adults support the fuel-price protests, and similar sentiments prevailed on the Continent. "You should do this every day — it's much more pleasant around here," chirped a fashionably clad young woman to trucker Madani Elalyane, whose big dump truck blocked the Schuman roundabout at the heart of the E.U.'s headquarters in Brussels. Much of that solidarity stems from the pain citizens bear in common with the truckers from fuel prices that have ballooned by more than a third this year alone.
Last week's wake-up call was not merely a response to higher oil prices, though. Europe's governments traditionally present themselves as being able to solve all the electorate's problems. That was always an exaggeration, but in an increasingly integrated global economy, such claims quickly encounter harsh reality. "Globalization has steadily eaten away the central role of the state, and taken much of its former economic dominance and margin of maneuver away," says Dominique Moïsi, deputy director of the French Institute of Foreign Relations. "What these protests do is restore some of that centrality to governments by insisting they correct market-driven developments."
For the past decade, Europeans have been told that a stronger, more tightly integrated and ever-larger E.U. would help them withstand the rigors of international competition. They were also assured that a single currency would enable Europe to stand up to the economic might of the U.S. But in the past two years E.U. citizens have come to question the benefits of integration and enlargement. And the steady, if largely benign decline of the euro — it hit a new low of 85¢ last week — has two-thirds of Germans saying they'd rather keep their deutsche mark.
Europeans' vague discontent with the state of the world has been exacerbated in recent months by the painful spike in oil prices. The public demands action from its leaders, the ones who promised they would forge a way through the changes wrought by globalization. But the main reason for the run-up in the price of crude oil — OPEC's production restrictions coupled with the soaring demand for energy by an expanding global economy — are not matters that Tony Blair or German Chancellor Gerhard Schröder or E.U. President Romano Prodi can effectively tackle. Taxation, which makes up the lion's share of pump prices throughout Europe, can be lowered; but then spending must be cut as well. The marketplace and the rules of E.U. membership set tough standards of fiscal prudence that governments disregard at a high cost.
A stronger euro would help lower the cost of motor fuel, since the world price of crude is set in dollars. Indeed, the currency's 26% drop against the dollar since it was introduced in January 1999 is responsible for a hefty portion of Europe's oil price hike since then. But the perils of a politician saying anything about the fledgling currency should by now be abundantly clear. Schröder's frank admission on Sept. 7 that the weak euro's positive effect on European exports made it "more of a reason to be happy than concerned" sent the euro to a new low against the dollar.
Last week's public unrest also shows up another of Europe's dilemmas: the countries have inextricably tied themselves together in the E.U.'s single market, but they often are unable to act in concert or even concordance. For all the heady talk of harmonization of economic policy, European governments reacted to the truckers' protests with a hodgepodge demonstration of how political necessity is still defined on national grounds. The French government started the ball rolling by granting up to $2,400 per truck in rebates on fuel taxes to offset the 36% rise in oil prices since the start of the year. That alone will cost the government $396 million; added to that is $63 million more in retroactive rebates on diesel fuel for farmers.
That response — an all but total success for the protesters — certainly whetted the appetite of farmers and truckers elsewhere in Europe for direct action. The governments of France's neighbors, however, weren't so quick to cave in to the demonstrators' demands. Even the congenitally weak Belgian government, an unwieldy coalition of liberals, socialists and environmentalists, refused to follow France in mandating a discount diesel price for professional truckers. The government did roll out a package of other deals — including postponing the payment deadline for road taxes and reducing levies on insurance payments, but they were small beer compared to the concessions of its larger southern neighbor. "In a comparable situation, Belgium maintained its sangfroid better than France," crowed Brussels daily Le Soir in a front-page editorial.
Page One | Two
|
|
|
|
September 25, 2000
COVER STORY
Running on Empty
Protests against rising fuel costs should be a wake-up call for European governments that have lost touch with their electorates
Let Them Ride Bikes
European motorists are fed up with ever-higher fuel taxes
EUROPE
Radical Czechs
As thousands of antiglobalization protesters prepare to take to the streets, Prague braces for the worst
The Police
Can cops in Prague keep their cool?
MIDDLE EAST
Miracle Makers
Israel's Shas Party is tapping into mysticism to give its politics more potency
OLYMPICS
The Real Australia
Americans know a lot about the place, most of it wrong. Our art critic evokes its true glories and flaws as only a native son can
DEPARTMENTS
Techwatch
World Watch
WHAT DO YOU THINK?
E-mail us at mail@timeatlantic.com
|
|
