Getting Rich off Those Who Work for Free
(2 of 2)
Clever entrepreneurs and even established companies can profit from this volunteerism--but only if they don't get too greedy. The key, Benkler says, is "managing the marriage of money and nonmoney without making nonmoney feel like a sucker." In software, where IBM and other companies charge billions of dollars to install and run otherwise free Linux systems, this seems to be working--in part because Linux volunteers can make money from their expertise and there's a clear understanding of what one can charge for.
In other fields, it's not so clear. In a critique of Benkler's work last summer, business writer Nicholas Carr speculated that Web 2.0 media sites like Digg, Flickr and YouTube are able to rely on volunteer contributions simply because a market has yet to emerge to price this "new kind of labor." He and Benkler then entered into what has come to be widely known in Web circles as the "Carr-Benkler wager": a bet on whether, by 2011, such sites will be driven primarily by volunteers or by professionals.
It's tempting for any professional journalist to root for Carr. I certainly don't want to be replaced by volunteers. But then, this magazine couldn't be produced without the volunteers, such as Yochai Benkler, who allow us journalists to interview them. Cable TV news channels are pageants of volunteerism, with much airtime filled by unpaid guests. The majority of these people aren't motivated by Kropotkin's spirit of mutual aid--they seek fame, an audience for their ideas, higher fees on the speaking circuit. But for those minutes on air, they are working for free.
To read Justin Fox's daily take on business, go to time-blog.com/curious_capitalist
- « PREV PAGE
- 1
- 2
Most Popular »
- The State of Hillary: A Mixed Record on the Job
- Powerhouse Priests Spar Over What it Means to Be Catholic
- The Ft. Hood Hero: Who is Kimberly Munley?
- Are You Getting Scammed by Facebook Games?
- The Meaning of Manny Pacquiao
- Hunting for Tuna: The Environmental Peril Grows
- The Quicksilver Mess
- Indie Film Shakeout: There Will Be Blood
- Troubles for a Deal and for Obama in Honduras
- Is the Dollar Dying a Slow Death?
- Powerhouse Priests Spar Over What it Means to Be Catholic
- Are You Getting Scammed by Facebook Games?
- The State of Hillary: A Mixed Record on the Job
- Hunting for Tuna: The Environmental Peril Grows
- The Meaning of Manny Pacquiao
- Is the Dollar Dying a Slow Death?
- Indie Film Shakeout: There Will Be Blood
- Hasan's Therapy: Could "Secondary Trauma" Have Driven Him to Shooting?
- Inside the Autistic Mind
- 'I Am Autism': An Advocacy Video Sparks Protest







RSS