The Battle For Berlin
(2 of 2)
The dealmaking worked both ways. In the case of a big new Bundesrat office building on Schiffbauerdamm, another Wertheim property, Hertie assigned its rights to the government for just j700,000, a fraction of the estimated €20 million that the government would have had to pay at market prices. "Governments the world over give sweetheart deals," says Gary Osen, a U.S. lawyer whose suit in a New Jersey court on behalf of the Wertheim family helped to unearth some of these details. "What you don't see a lot of and what makes this alarming is that the government is writing checks."
If the government isn't talking, Osen and his client Barbara Principe are. She's a 70-year-old mother of seven children who grew up on a chicken farm in New Jersey, barely aware that her grandfather Franz Wertheim was co-owner of a German retail legend. In 1951 a German lawyer named Arthur Lindgens, a distant relative by marriage of the Wertheim family, bought out Principe's father's and uncle's share for the equivalent of about $5,100 at the time. That enabled Lindgens to get majority control of Wertheim, and he promptly sold it to Hertie. "My father was told there was nothing left. It was a total lie," Principe says.
|
|||||
Indeed, the German ambassador in Washington, Wolfgang Ischinger, in January wrote to the New Jersey judge who is considering Principe's suit in the U.S., urging him to dismiss that case. It should, according to the ambassador, be subsumed by the 2000 agreement. Principe's lawyers filed an angry rebuttal, saying the ambassador's letter "inexcusably" failed to disclose the German government's own "substantial pecuniary interest" in the case. Behind the scenes, the German Foreign Ministry has been trying to convince the Bush Administration to intervene to dismiss the case, so far to no avail, according to letters to the U.S. State Department obtained by TIME. Significantly, Stuart E. Eizenstat, the former Deputy U.S. Treasury Secretary who negotiated the 2000 accord, believes it doesn't cover the Wertheim case. Eizenstat accepts the argument by Principe's lawyers that her family was defrauded after the war's end. "It speaks volumes that the U.S. government has not intervened," Eizenstat tells TIME.
Perhaps none of this would have emerged had it not been for 38-year-old German former law student Simone Ladwig-Winters. In the early 1990s, she started working on a doctoral thesis about the way the Wertheim empire was "Aryanized" by the Nazis. Among other things, she discovered that Hitler's lieutenant Hermann Göring in December 1937 personally ordered the firm's name to be changed, and all Jewish shareholders and employees to be ousted. Winters is now working with another writer on a historical novel about the family, and seems taken aback by the legal avalanche she helped to set off. Her research is being used by all the claimants and the courts. "When I started looking into this, people didn't seem very interested," she recalls. They are now.
The next legal steps are uncertain. Germany's supreme court is expected to settle once and for all the ownership question, although not for another couple of years at the earliest. The federal judge in the New Jersey case is expected to rule much sooner, probably in early fall, whether to admit Principe's suit. And it's possible that the government will try to restart the settlement talks that broke down last year. In the meantime, on the spot in Leipziger Platz where Berliners once flocked to buy their hats, silverware and sausage, the weeds continue to grow.
- « PREV PAGE
- 1
- 2
Most Popular »
- The Pentagon Prepares for a Missile Attack from 'Iran'
- Israel vs. Hizballah: Drumbeats of War
- Snow Job for the Avatar Opening?
- Health Reform's Senate Win: Did Reid Make It Tougher Than It Had to Be?
- Iran's Opposition Loses a Mentor But Gains a Martyr
- The Conquerors of the Tigers Now Battle for the Spoils
- Sarkozy Stands By France's Hated Immigration Minister
- In Nigeria, an Ailing President and Peace Process
- U.S. Companies Shut Out as Iraq Auctions Its Oil Fields
- The Year in Viral Videos
- Agent Orange Poisons New Generations in Vietnam
- U.S. Companies Shut Out as Iraq Auctions Its Oil Fields
- In Nigeria, an Ailing President and Peace Process
- Autism Numbers Are Rising. The Question is Why?
- Corliss Appraises Avatar: A World of Wonder
- Iran's Opposition Loses a Mentor But Gains a Martyr
- The Pentagon Prepares for a Missile Attack from 'Iran'
- Health Reform's Senate Win: Did Reid Make It Tougher Than It Had to Be?
- Testosterone: Not Always an Aggression Booster
- The Many Faces of Thom Mayne's 41 Cooper Square





RSS