The Cost of Kissing and Not Telling

For most people, the thought of publicly disclosing their sexual secrets is the stuff of Freudian nightmares. But last year, after Martin (not his real name), an electrical worker, was sued by his former girlfriend in New York City, he was required to answer a lawyer's questions on intimate details of his sexual activities: "Did you ever suffer from blisters or sores on your penis or genitals?" "Did you ever have difficulty achieving or keeping an erection during sexual intercourse?" Martin discovered that the true fury of hell is not a woman scorned but a woman who contracts genital herpes from her lover.

Increasingly, outraged spouses and lovers -- most of them women -- are suing their partners for infecting them with the sometimes painful and debilitating condition. Genital herpes, most commonly caused by the herpes simplex Type 2 virus, is thought to have infected up to 20 million Americans, and has no cure. The surge of litigation is largely based on the claim that one partner did not inform the other about his or her infection. This, the suits often charge, constitutes negligence.

These claims are being given momentum by an appellate court ruling last December in New York, a state that exerts substantial legal influence beyond its boundaries. The decision upheld the right of Jane Maharam, 56, to sue her former husband Robert, 56, on her claim that he had herpes and did not tell her. The court found that such partners have a legal duty to inform each other about their venereal diseases. Jane, who was married to Robert, an entrepreneur, for 31 years before the couple were divorced in 1984, is seeking damages of more than $2.5 million. The manager of a record company in Manhattan, she says she had few reservations about filing a suit charging Robert with giving her herpes. "There's a stigma," she says, "but I have to conquer those feelings because I know I have to do this."

Even before the New York case, courts in several other states had allowed plaintiffs to sue their partners for transmitting sexual diseases. That, lawyers say, may lead to a freshet of cases involving acquired immunodeficiency syndrome, or AIDS. Louis Alexander, a Syracuse attorney who has studied civil actions involving sexually transmitted diseases, notes that over the past two decades the legal system has become more sympathetic to the injured party. "With herpes and AIDS, we're dealing with diseases that are incurable," he says. "My view is that there should be a legal duty to disclose them."

One well-publicized herpes suit has been filed in Manhattan Supreme Court by Linda Feldman, a 24-year-old cellist, against Singer Tony Bennett, 60. Feldman claims damages of $90 million, saying the singer infected her during an eight- month affair that began in 1985. Feldman says that after she discovered her infection, Bennett told her, "I've had it for years. You get used to it. It's God's way of giving your sex life a rest." Bennett, who has produced medical records claiming that he does not have the ailment, has filed a $100 million counterclaim for defamation.

1. Is It Time to Invade Burma?
2. The Five Mistakes Clinton Made
3. Obama: How He Learned to Win
4. Klein on Obama
5. Santa Vs. Interpol
6. 'American Idol' Dad's Backstage Ban
7. Burma's Faceless Leaders
8. Obama Takes Superdelegate Lead
9. Hitting a Nuclear Roadblock
10. Stressed Out in India's Tech Capital

You will need to install or upgrade your Flash Player to be able to view this Flash content. Also, Javascript must be turned on.

Grab it! to put Quotes of the Day on your personal page or blog