When Australia's Prime Minister John Howard met last week
with Indonesia's President Abdurrahman Wahid at the apec summit
in Brunei, the picture was one of distant friends trying to
smooth over awkward differences. Both men know the relationship
is strained; some analysts say it's seldom been worse. The
meeting, their third since Wahid took office in 1999, offers
hope for improvement. But the apparent discovery of Free Papua
Movement (o.p.m.) guerrilla bases in neighboring Papua New
Guinea could add further strain.
In recent weeks, Howard and Foreign Minister Alexander Downer
have gone to great lengths to reassure Jakarta that despite
the West Papuans' growing push for independence Canberra recognizes
Indonesia's sovereignty over the province. Yet if confirmed,
o.p.m.'s presence in P.N.G. would be a problem not only for
Port Moresby but also for Canberra, which is seen by some
in Indonesia as P.N.G.'s defense underwriter.
According to Indonesian news agency Antara, Vice-President
Megawati Sukarnoputri sought assurances from P.N.G. in September
that it would not support the separatist movement. Megawati
is also reported to have gained a commitment from P.N.G. Prime
Minister Sir Mekere Morauta to improve border security.
P.N.G. Chief Secretary Robert Igara told Time that Port Moresby
is aware of its obligations "not to allow our territory to
be used as a base for hostile acts against a neighboring country."
But securing the border will not be easy. A review in October
found that the P.N.G. Defence Force could not maintain national
security interests. Igara cites other "challenges involved
in effective management of the border area": rugged terrain;
inadequate communications and transport infrastructure; and
the rights of local landowners.
The border is a key security issue for Australia as well
as P.N.G. Illegal crossings-whether by West Papuan refugees
fleeing repression, by Indonesian armed forces (t.n.i.) pursuing
rebels, or by rebels seeking sanctuary in P.N.G.-could worsen
both countries' relations with Indonesia. The refugee problem
is not pressing, although the Australia West Papua Association's
John Wing says there are "unrecognized refugees" still on
the border. A number of alleged t.n.i. incursions have been
investigated in recent years-each time prompting P.N.G. to
deal, says Igara, "firmly through diplomatic channels with
alleged violations of sovereignty."
But what of the guerrilla camps? o.p.m. Supreme Commander
John Koknak says P.N.G. is an appropriate site, given the
artificiality of the border and the kinship between West Papuans
and local people. Any attempts by P.N.G. authorities to remove
them, even at Australia's insistence, would be resisted, he
adds. But failure by P.N.G. to act effectively could provoke
the t.n.i. Announcing a three-month offensive code-named Tuntas,
which began on Nov. 10, Indonesian police Senior Superintendent
Kusnadi told the Jakarta Post a special operation might be
launched to disperse the separatist camps: that could mean
further, more serious incursions.
If Jakarta presses the issue of secret bases, or if the t.n.i.
goes on the attack, Canberra would have to intercede, however
much it might wish to compartmentalize the question as one
for P.N.G. and Indonesia alone. As senior Australian Parliamentary
Library researcher June Verrier has found: "For Australia,
because of proximity, because of history and because of its
ongoing links with P.N.G., [West Papua] is likely to be just
as challenging to its relations with Indonesia as was the
situation in Timor." A P.N.G. failure to police the border
could be construed in Indonesia as Australia's failure, or-in
the worst case-as tacit support for the o.p.m. According to
an Australian government insider, separatist bases in P.N.G.,
while "not quite Australia's nightmare scenario," would be
a "significantly thorny issue."
The Australian Defence Force Academy's Stewart Woodman says
the "clever role" for Australia would be to act as a neutral
broker in establishing fresh agreement between Jakarta and
Port Moresby on border controls and the o.p.m. In the past,
P.N.G. authorities have acted against the o.p.m. only when
"they feel they have to," says Peter King, an Australian expert
on West Papua. "That's partly Indonesian pressure and partly
Australian pressure." P.N.G. Chief Secretary Igara says that
if rebel camps are located, efforts would be made "to remove
them or, at the least, to prevent their use for unlawful purposes."
But any arm-twisting by Australia would be disappointing,
says the o.p.m.'s Australian spokesman, John Ondawame. For
now, Canberra will be treading carefully. To preserve its
tenuous relationship with Jakarta, and ensure next month's
visit by an Indonesian ministerial delegation still goes ahead,
will take great charm and skill.