Time



THE WAY OF THE WEST IS POISON

Asia's challenge is to give its people the sweet taste of economic success without all the toxic side effects



BY ANIL AGARWAL


A deadly combination of poverty, rapid population growth and unmanaged industrialization--the result of poor governance--is rapidly turning Asia's industrial development into an environmental nightmare. Between 1975 and 1988, according to World Bank estimates, toxic releases went up 500% in Indonesia, 800% in the Philippines and 1,200% in Thailand. Asia's cities, rivers and lakes are among the world's most polluted, and its forests are severely depleted.

Many Asians are slowly beginning to realize that the Western industrial strategy, with its heavy use of raw materials and energy, is a highly toxic model. The West has been able to reduce its pollution and make its cities livable only because of the enormous investments it has made in pollution control and prevention since the 1960s. Moreover, the West has had a relatively stable population base. But with hundreds of millions of poor people aspiring to live like Westerners, most Asian countries want to adopt the Western model on the cheap, and in the process they may cook their own goose.

A fine example is demand for transportation in India. In the U.S., there is one car for every 1.6 people. If India were to have the same ratio, the number of cars in the country would have to grow from 3 million to more than 550 million. That's not likely to happen, but it's entirely possible that in two decades Indians will be riding on hundreds of millions of motor scooters that burn a mix of gasoline and oil and are less friendly to the environment than regular autos. These scooters account for 70% of the motor vehicles registered in India as of 1993, and most Asian cities are packed with similar smogmakers. If investments in highway and traffic infrastructure and smog-control technology lag behind, one can imagine widespread mayhem and pollution on the roads of the kind already seen in big cities from Bangkok to Delhi.

[  Page 1 | Page 2   ]