TIME's First Annual ReOscars

Richard Corliss, 10 Years Later

Best Supporting Actress

Moore nabs the ReOscar for her role as porn in the USA goddess Amber Waves.
Everett
Article Tools

Nominees
Kim Basinger: L.A. Confidential (Oscar winner)
Joan Cusack: In & Out
Minnie Driver: Good Will Hunting
JULIANNE MOORE: Boogie Nights (ReOscar winner)
Gloria Stuart: Titanic

Sorta slim pickin's here: four girlfriend roles, and a fifth (Stuart) playing the same role, 75 years later, as one of the Best Actress nominees (Winslet). Cusack was OK as the fluttery, flustery girlfriend of possibly-gay Kevin Kline. Driver: nothing to say but Why? Basinger, playing a used, bruised, Lana Turnerish non-starlet in '50s L.A., got the award for showing a tragic subtext to Hollywood glamour, and maybe for the tabloid entertainment value of her marriage to Alec Baldwin. It was good work, but to push my contrarian thesis I'm going with Moore. She might not have been superficially plausible as the porn goddess Amber Waves but she poured jeroboams of sympathy and pity into the part. Moore gets extra credit for her next role, as an artsy-smartsy siren in the Coen brothers' The Big Lebowski. Not even nominated for that spectacularly hilarious turn? She was robbed!

More Stories

The 25 Most Important Films on Race

In honor of Black History Month, TIME critic Richard Corliss reflects on 25 defining works over nearly a century of cinema that broke down the walls of intolerance on the big screen

The Morning Line on Oscar

The Academy Awards nominations are out. TIME's Richard Corliss picks the likely winners, his own favorites and the biggest snubs

The Top 10 Everything of 2007

From the best movies to the worst business deals, 50 lists that sum up the year -- and start all kinds of arguments