Grammy Awards 2010

TIME writer Claire Suddath grades the performances of the 2010 Grammy Awards

Lady Gaga

Musicians Elton John (L) and Lady Gaga perform onstage during the 52nd Annual GRAMMY Awards held at Staples Center on January 31, 2010 in Los Angeles, California

Kevin Winter / Getty Images

I'm sorry, is Lady Gaga singing? I'm too busy staring at her chest/crotch/enormous green glittery shoulder pads to notice. Actually, judging by her previous performances (see: the 2009 MTV Video Music Awards act in which she bled to death and hanged herself in one song, "Paparazzi"), her 52nd Grammy Awards opener seems fairly tame. But just when I begin to write her off as nothing but show, out comes Elton John to combine her "Speechless" and his "Your Song" in one sweeping act of dueling-piano-ballad glory.

Grade: A-

See Fergie, Bees and Puppets: Grammy's Best Videos

See pictures of Lady Gaga.

View the full list for "Grammy Awards 2010"