The Best Online Photo Services
We rate sites that will print your digital pics
January 16, 2004
Online photo-printing services have come a long way since they first emerged in the late 90s, when digital
photography was still an early-adopter enterprise. Prices have dropped to a nice comfortable level, the
prints look better and the websites are, for the most part, easier to use. And most make silver-halide
prints, the same professional grade you get with 35mm film prints (and a cut above ink-jet). To use, you
simply transfer your digital image files from your computer to the website (easier with a broadband
connection) and organize them into albums.
Most services allow you to add captions and make minor editing adjustments. You can order prints of all
conceivable sizes, create photo calendars and have your images printed on mugs, caps and other merchandise. Everything is shipped to your door within days. Here's the scoop on five of the most popular sites:
 |
 |
|
 |
Ease of Use |
 |
Prices |
 |
Print Quality |
 |
Comment |
 |
 |
 |
Ofoto |
 |
Uploading, organizing, sharing and ordering prints is easy enough |
 |
Reasonable: 29 cents for a 4x6 |
 |
Good; edges were sharp but skin tones lacked warmth; colors looked more natural in some cases, a bit dulled in others |
 |
Our calendar was easy to make and turned out beautifully |
 |
 |
 |
Shutterfly |
 |
Smooth sailing from start to finish; the calendar creator is a snap |
 |
The highest per-print rate we saw: 39 cents for a 4x6 |
 |
Pretty good; skin tones were often either too red or too yellow, and some prints lacked definition |
 |
After a blissful online experience, we expected to be blown away by the quality of the prints we weren't |
 |
 |
 |
Snapfish |
 |
Site is confusing and difficult to navigate; placing our order was frustrating |
 |
Competitive: 25 cents for a 4x6, 30 cents to print on heavyweight glossy paper |
 |
O.K., but inconsistent; colors are punchy which sometimes works, sometimes doesn't; handles black-and-white images nicely |
 |
It's been around a while, and gets lots of traffic, so we expected better |
 |
 |
 |
Sony ImageStation |
 |
Site is unwieldy, instructions confusing and incomplete; quite a few false starts undermined our trial |
 |
4x6 prints are 29 cents each; some sales lower this to 19 cents |
 |
Very good; produced best balance of color and light |
 |
Pay a premium per-print price and the site's technicians will make minor improvements (fix red-eye, adjust contrast) |
 |
 |
 |
Wal-Mart Photo Center |
 |
Straightforward and intuitive |
 |
24 cents for a 4x6 |
 |
Usually acceptable, occasionally outstanding; in some cases, colors looked washed out |
 |
After 30 days images disappear from the website unless you purchase longer-term storage; can receive online order at a physical store |
 |
 |
Some general tips:
Photo-printing services can't work magic. A blurry shot will come back blurry.
You can use your own photo-editing software installed on your computer (basic programs go for $29 to $49) to fix red-eye or crop your shots before you upload them to the service or you can make these adjustments using the site's own tools.
Be sure to upload full-size files for best results. Most services (and all of the ones listed here) will tell you if an image is not good enough to print at a particular size, but there are no rules, only guidelines.
Digital images typically do not conform to the standard print dimensions so most services will zoom a little and trim a little unless you specifically tell them not to. One of my favorite shots of my two sons was, unfortunately, ill-framed. To keep Conor's chin, you had to slice off the top of Dylan's head. I had five services print this photo and each one trimmed it slightly differently. Snapfish and Photoaccess.com (not represented above) are among the few services that offer non-standard-size prints.
|